How to Choose a College

Evan Castillo
By
Updated on June 9, 2025
Edited by
Reviewed by
Our Integrity Network

BestColleges.com is committed to delivering content that is objective and actionable. To that end, we have built a network of industry professionals across higher education to review our content and ensure we are providing the most helpful information to our readers.

Drawing on their firsthand industry expertise, our Integrity Network members serve as an additional step in our editing process, helping us confirm our content is accurate and up to date. These contributors:

  • Suggest changes to inaccurate or misleading information.
  • Provide specific, corrective feedback.
  • Identify critical information that writers may have missed.

Integrity Network members typically work full time in their industry profession and review content for BestColleges.com as a side project. All Integrity Network members are paid members of the Red Ventures Education Integrity Network.

Explore our full list of Integrity Network members.

Learn more about our editorial process
Having trouble deciding where to go to college? Check out our step-by-step guide on finding your school.

How do you choose the place you’ll spend years at, explore your interests and passions, and start the journey to your career?

Carefully.

Choosing a college is daunting, but if you approach it well prepared, you’ll end up at the right place. Weigh what’s important to you — including budget, academics, and culture —and see what schools check off the most boxes on your list.

No college is a perfect fit, but the best ones are those you can feel comfortable at and build a community while being challenged academically.

Read the Video Transcriptchevron-right

How to Pick the Right College for You

Follow these six steps to help guide you through choosing and applying to the college that fits you best.

Download our free comparison chart PDF tool to help you choose between colleges.

Step 1: Consider Your Wants and Needs

Take account of your non-negotiables — your needs— and what would be nice to have. Here’s a list of variables to get you started:

  • Location: Do you want to stay close to home or move cross-country? Somewhere in between? If you have a part- or full-time job or a family, an online college may suit you best.
  • Budget: Private schools tend to be more expensive than public schools, and in-state schools are often cheaper than out-of-state schools. However, different schools may offer you financial aid that makes some “more expensive” colleges cheaper than others.
  • Academics: Is the school well known for what you want to major in? If you don’t know what you want to study, choose colleges with broad selections of majors in science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM); humanities; social sciences; and liberal arts.
  • Reputation: Sometimes a good reputation can get you far in your job applications. Is your school well known? Prestigious? Or known in your community? What is the school’s admission rate? Graduation rate?
  • Campus culture: What kind of environment do you prefer? Some may seek student bodies that are academically rigorous, diverse, politically active, artistic, party-friendly, or sporty.

Step 2: Create a List of Colleges

It’s a good idea to make a list of schools in a few different categories: safety, target, and reach schools. These should reflect your values in a college and have a mix of some priorities over others.

  • Safety: These are schools that you are fairly confident you can get into and can be backups if you don’t get into your target or reach schools.
  • Target: These are schools that you have a good chance of getting into. They should balance attainability, cost, environment, academics, and other factors you’re seeking.
  • Reach: These schools are academically rigorous and selective, so you have a smaller chance at getting in. Some popular reach schools include the Ivy League or other prestigious schools. Even some out-of-state public universities can be reach schools if they favor in-state students.

Step 3: Visit College Campuses

After you’ve created your list of schools, try visiting some schools in each category. Sometimes a school can look great on paper, but it might have a different vibe on campus, so it’s good to keep an open mind.

You can book a university-official tour, go with your friends and family, or link up with a friend who goes to the university to see the campus culture and study and living spaces for yourself. If the school is farther away and more difficult to visit, you can always start with an online tour.

    Step 4: Apply to Colleges

    Once you’ve narrowed down your list, it’s a good idea to apply to at least 5-10 schools. Typically, you’ll have until May 1 to decide on a school. There’s a few ways you can apply:

    • Early Action: This is a nonbinding (you don’t have to accept an offer) college application that gets you an answer from colleges the soonest.
    • Early Decision I and II: This is a binding decision where you must agree to attend that school if accepted.
    • Regular Decision: A nonbinding college application after early action.
    • Rolling Admissions: You can apply at almost any time of the year and receive a response from your college as soon as they receive your application and review it.

    Some common things you’ll need to include in your applications are:

    Step 5: Compare Financial Aid Offers

    Once you get your offers back, compare each school’s financial aid package to see where the best bang for your buck is.

    See what schools offer the best grant and scholarship aid, which you won’t have to pay back. Remember, if you take out student loans, you’ll have to pay those back with interest.

    You also may be eligible for “work-study.” Work-study jobs are part-time jobs offered by the university where you can earn some money with flexible hours to pay for tuition and fees, books, or other living expenses.

    Step 6: Make a Pros and Cons List

    Now you’re at the final step, making the college decision. Write down all the pros and cons for the schools you were accepted to. Here are a few things to compare:

    • The largest financial aid offers
    • What you learned from visiting some campuses
    • The culture at the school
    • How far the school is from home
    • The majors offered at the school
    Loading...
    Loading...Learn More
    Visit Site
    Loading...
    Loading...Learn More
    Visit Site
    Loading...
    Loading...Learn More
    Visit Site

    Frequently Asked Questions About Picking a College

    A few important factors to consider are location, budget, academics, culture, and reputation. Ask yourself what you’re looking for in each of these categories and weigh them to see what you prioritize and what you can compromise on.

    Explore More College Resources

    Ask a College Advisor: How Do I Know If a College Is a Good Fit for Me?

    Ask a College Advisor: How Do I Know If a College Is a Good Fit for Me?

    Hear from one of our experts on which factors are the most important for you to consider when choosing a college.

    Lauren Albano

    by Lauren Albano

    Updated February 28, 2022

    How to Choose an Online College

    How to Choose an Online College

    There are more remote learning options to choose from than ever. Discover how to choose the best online college for you.

    Doug Wintemute

    by Doug Wintemute

    Updated May 16, 2023

    How Much Does College Really Cost?

    How Much Does College Really Cost?

    Most families don’t pay “sticker price” for college, but learning the ins and outs of financial aid offers can be daunting. Here are some tips.

    Mark J. Drozdowski, Ed.D.

    by Mark J. Drozdowski, Ed.D.

    Updated May 3, 2022